Came across an interview with Brian that TriMax Fitness posted recently, in which they call him “The Most Dangerous Man in Endurance” and then use an unnecessary exclamation point. Grammar aside, it’s a good read. Here’s an excerpt:
If Chris McCormack came to you and said “I want to win Kona this year (again)” how would you train him?
I’d tell him I can’t train him. An athlete like that is such a specialist that it would take me 2-3 years just to get him moving correctly enough to handle what I wanted to do to him. If I had 2-3 years and we could change his nutrition, and put some size and strength on him, all the while he still could move efficiently, then I would never let him do an unnecessary mile or minute of training again. Unfortunately, he probably wouldn’t be able to wrap his head around that, and have a break down, and secretly go out and swim/bike/run real long. I can’t give you his code for training because they are all different, but I can tell you he would not only not survive with me but would not win Kona if I only had a year.
The article has inspired (instigated?) quite a firestorm amongst the forum-folks of Slowtwitch, their major beef seeming to be the argument that until people who are utilizing CrossFit and CFE as their training regime start placing higher at Tri’s, then they’re going to stick with their LSD. That, and it seems they don’t like tattoos very much.
It seems to me, after reading through as much as I could handle (they start to get repetitive after about 5 or 6 pages), that it boils down to two things: Results and Perception.
The LSD crowd claims to see no results, while Brian and the CFE folks claim to have them. Brian, again in the TriMax interview:
When you look back at all the endless hours you spent in long, slow distance work you did prior to CrossFit Endurance, what are your biggest regrets?
Not one! We basically wrote a PHD in our experience from LSD to CFE. Will we ever be recognized like that? Not by anyone I care to be around or look up too. I’ve studied HR, VO2 Max, blood lactate, and everything that goes with it. I’ve got 5+ years of heart rate data on clients and my own training. I’ve got a VO2 Machine that I used to use for everyone I trained. I’ve personally tested blood lactate levels on hundreds of athletes. It all came down to this… When we got rid of the slow stuff, added intensity, and heavy weights, everyone got faster, and everyone got healthier.
And perception: The notion that the only way to have the capacity to S/B/R long is to swim long, bike long and run long.
Perhaps the latter will fall if the former does? And can results only be substantive if they come in the form of winning races?
Either way, it certainly indicates a fundamental divide in training philosophies.
You can read the full interview with Brian here.
Safe training,
Patrick

